LA GRANDE, Ore. - The No. 14-ranked Carroll Football team forced overtime on a 30-yard field goal with just nine seconds left in regulation, but ultimately fell in overtime on the road at Eastern Oregon on Saturday afternoon at Community Stadium.
The Fighting Saints (7-3, 4-2) forced four turnovers on Saturday, recovering three EOU fumbles and blocking a field goal, while piling-up 421 yards of offense, but couldn't find the end zone in overtime falling to the Mountaineers (8-2, 5-1).
Both offenses struggled to find a rhythm early. Carroll's first two possessions netted a total of negative yards and ending in punts. Eastern Oregon took advantage of the field position. On their second possession of the afternoon, EOU went five plays in 1:43 to put the first points of the game on the board. Chase Nelson hit Montana Western-transfer Dylan Shipley for 36-yards on a fourth-and-two, setting up a five-yard touchdown pass on the very next play to go up 7-0.
Carroll's defense settled-in a bit, while the offense still needed some time to get rolling. Johnny Miller (Lake Oswego, Ore. / SR) recovered a fumble forced by Alex Hausmann (Kalispell, Mont. / R-SO) late in the opening quarter, and the unit would go on to force a string of EOU punts, including three in the first quarter alone.
The Saints finally got on the board in the second quarter. After taking over at their own 28-yard line, Carroll went 10 plays and 56 yards on a drive that would ultimately stall-out at the EOU 16. Eddie Ballanco (Bozeman, Mont. / FR) came on and nailed a 33-yarder, making things 7-3 with six minutes left in the half.
Nelson would find Shipley again on the next EOU drive with a 56-yard connection to move the Mounties into the redzone in a hurry, but the Saints' defense stiffened, forcing EOU to attempt a kick as well. Kolbe Coey (Hayden, Idaho / R-FR) breathed life into the Saints, breaking through to block a 33-yard field goal attempt, and give Carroll possession with a chance to take the lead late in the half. The Saints couldn't take advantage, however, and Eastern Oregon took a 7-3 lead into the break.
The second half opened with a quick turnover. Eli Aby (Laurel, Mont. / R-SR) both forced, and recovered, a fumble in plus-territory on EOU's opening possession, but Carroll again failed to capitalize. The Saints turned it right back over on downs, letting the Mounties off the hook.
Eastern Oregon made the Saints pay, going 64-yards in just six plays, capped by a 26-yard touchdown pass to make it 14-3 just minutes into the third.
Held without a touchdown in the first half, the Carroll offense finally fought back. Near midfield, Kaden Huot (Helena, Mont. / SR) connected with Connor Sullivan (Kalispell, Mont. / R-SR) for a 49-yard touchdown, quickly cutting the lead to 14-10.
The Mountaineers responded with an eight-play, 75-yard drive that ended with a second-straight Tyler Creswick touchdown reception, this one from 28, to push the lead up to ten. A missed extra point attempt failed though, leaving EOU ahead 20-10.
That missed kick proved significant. On the first play of the ensuing possession, Huot hit a wide open Ethan Triplett (Belt, Mont. / R-SO) in stride and Triplett raced 70-yards completely untouched for a touchdown, just nine seconds after the Mountaineers had scored, pulling Carroll within three at 20-17.
Eastern Oregon put together a long, grinding drive that stretched from the end of the third quarter into the fourth. Running back Waylon Riedel carried the load, as EOU worked all the way down to the Carroll two-yard line. The Carroll defense dug-in with their heels on the goal line, forcing a Riedel fumble that an opportunistic Coey would recover with under 10 to play.
The Saints then put together perhaps their best drive of the day, going 79-yards in 5:33. Huot found Sullivan for gains of 34 and 21 yards, and Peter Minnaert (Boise, Idaho / JR) added a 17-yard reception, moving Carroll to the EOU 16, but the drive would eventually stall short. Ballanco came on to attempt 32-yard field goal try into the wind, but his kick hit the left upright, and the Saints came away empty-handed with just 3:51 left.
Carroll's defense held again, forcing a punt that gave the offense the ball at its own 25 with 58 seconds remaining and no timeouts to spare. Huot moved the Saints 62-yards in seven plays, and with nine seconds left Ballanco would redeem himself, putting a last second field goal up and good from 30 yards to tie the game at 20-20 and force OT.
Carroll had the ball first in overtime, but made a decision to go for it on fourth-and-two unsuccessfully, coming away with nothing on their lone possession in the extra frame.
Eastern Oregon needed only four plays from the 25 to win it. Malakai Nutter ran for nineyards, Nelson scrambled for 15 down to the Carroll 1, and after a no-gain run, Nutter punched it in from a yard out for the 26-20 overtime win, severely changing the postseason picture for both teams.
Huot finished 14-of-28 for 313 yards and two touchdowns, but was sacked five times in the loss. Sullivan caught a season-best six passes for 112-yards and a score, Triplett had two catches for 88 yards and a touchdown, while Ty Wilkinson (Pocatello, Idaho / R-SO) finished with just three catches for 43 yards. Peter Minnaert paced the ground game with 59 yards on 17 carries.
Defensively, Kolbe Coey finished with six tackles, a blocked field goal, and a fumble recovery, while Dylin McIntyre (Kennewick, Wash. / R-SO) and Johnny Miller added six tackles apiece, with McIntyre recording a sack.
Eastern Oregon out-gained Carroll on the ground 217-108 and held a 23-15 edge in first downs, but the Saints won the passing battle 313-285.
A win would have all but guaranteed the Saints a spot in the NAIA Football Championship Series, but Saturday's loss puts a severe damper on a second-straight postseason appearance for Carroll. The Saints are still in the conversation, but now find themselves fully at the mercy of the NAIA National Selection Committee, hoping to hear their name called in Sunday evening's Championship Selection Show at 5 p.m.
Be sure visit www.carrollathletics.com for complete coverage of the Fighting Saints all season long.
FOLLOW THE FIGHTING SAINTS
Facebook: @carrollcollegeathletics
Instagram: @cc_saints
X: @CCsaints
#MarchOn
++